Rev. Patti Money
Cheriton/Travis Chapel UMC
Isaiah 43:1-7
July 22, 2012
"The God Who Doesn't Meet Our Expectations"
Monday afternoon, after having lunch with someone in Cape Charles, I got into my car and used my cell phone to check my e-mail. There were the usual mass e-mails promoting this, that, or the other thing. And then I saw one from the District Office, with the subject “prayer concern”, when I opened that e-mail and read the contents, my heart dropped to my knees as I read the news that one of our Eastern Shore clergy, who was also an EMT and a volunteer fireman, had died while responding to a call with the Bloxum Fire Department. His name was David Chew, he was 30 years old, and while he had not been a close friend, I had known him for six years and certainly considered him a friend. Many of you heard the news that afternoon or the next morning, and I know that some of you knew David also, probably even better than I did. Even if you didn’t know David personally, the thought of a young man in our community, who was in the prime of life and who dedicated his life to serving others, dying a sudden death is heart-wrenching. It shakes us up. It makes us question.
On Friday morning, as we woke up and checked the newspaper, watched the news on TV, or read the news online, we heard that a gunman had entered a packed movie theatre in Colorado, and opened fire on a group of people watching a midnight showing of the new Batman movie. Twelve people were killed; over fifty people were injured. It is the sort of senseless violence and devastating news that affects all of us on some emotional level, even though we live thousands of miles from the Denver area and may not know anyone personally affected by this tragedy. It shakes us up. It makes us question.
Why...why does God let these sorts of things happen? How can God let these things happen? Why didn’t God save David Chew, who was in “full flower”, had so much potential, and leaves behind a wife and child. Why didn’t God stop James Holmes from going into that movie theatre, from buying those guns and ammunition, from pulling the trigger? Why were some people killed or injured and others were not? Why did the crash of a fire truck result in one person walking away with minor injuries and another losing his life? God did not meet our expectations. And that was the crux of the matter for those of us who put David Chew to rest on Friday, for those who were directly impacted by the movie theatre shooting, for those of us who watched the horror on the news, and it is something we face every day of our existence, especially in the hardest times: we expect that a God of infinite love, infinite power, and infinite knowledge would prevent disasters large and small from occurring. But that just doesn’t happen, does it? God does not meet our expectations. Even when it seems like we’re doing everything “right”, even when we’re perfectly in line with God’s will, bad things still happen in the world. A 30-year-old pastor and firefighter dies in the line of duty. Innocent people attending opening night of a movie are shot and killed. Our loved ones get cancer and die. We lose our jobs. Friends betray us. We expect that if we love God, if we follow God’s will, if we put our faith and trust in God, that everything will be fine…and so often it isn’t fine. God does not meet our expectations.
The key words are “our expectations”. Because that’s exactly what they are: our expectations for who we expect God to be and what we expect God to do versus what scripture tells us about who God is and what God does.
If you look carefully through scripture, you certainly see many, many stories of God intervening on behalf of God’s people, both groups and individuals. However, you also see many times when God appeared not to intervene, or waited a while to intervene. And most of the time when God did intervene and heal the sick, raise the dead, win a battle, not everyone was spared. There were still casualties. So, what do we do with that? When we continue to look at scripture, we see one consistent theme throughout the Bible: God promises to be with His people, and fulfills that promise, whether or not we are aware of it, or even whether or not we believe it. That’s the promise we hear in today’s scripture reading, from Isaiah 43:
This passage was most likely written during a time when the bulk of the population of Israel was in exile in Babylon, a land far, far away from Israel. God’s people had been unfaithful, had broken God’s laws, and had paid for it by being conquered by a foreign army and deported to Babylon. That’s the simple story. The Israelites had been through a difficult time, were going through a difficult time, and were facing difficult times ahead of them. This part of Isaiah is speaking hope to them…and speaks hope to us in the 21st century.
Listen to the language of the passage: do not fear…when this happens…when that happens…when the other thing happens…God knows that these things will happen, that tragedy and pain and suffering will come into our lives. But listen to the words in between…I created you…I formed you…I redeemed you…I have called you by name…you are mine…I will be with you. I love you.
The promise contained in these words is twofold. First, there is the promise that God is with us through thick and thin, that God will never leave us or forsake us, and that God is walking with us and giving us His comfort and peace through even the darkest night and lowest low. Second, there is the promise of redemption…which is a fancy church word meaning changing something for the better. God takes the pain and suffering of our lives and of this world and redeems it…makes something good out of what was bad. It’s the message of all of scripture…Adam Hamilton, who is the pastor of Church of the Resurrection, a United Methodist church in Kansas City, says it best: “The overarching message of the Bible is that God brings life out of death and good out of evil.”
At David Chew’s funeral on Friday afternoon, Rev. Alex Joyner, who is the pastor of Franktown UMC and helped lead the service, shared a story from Monday night. He and several others were at the Chew residence, and the talking had faded into silence. Suddenly, David and Becky Chew’s three-year-old son, Little David, climbed into his mother’s lap and said that he wanted to sing. So, this little boy who had just lost his Daddy, who may not have understood exactly what was going on, but certainly was able to pick up on the sad mood, sang a solo of “Jesus Loves Me”. And five days later, over five hundred voices sang the same song at David’s funeral...Jesus loves me, this I know, for the Bible tells me so. Little ones to him belong, they are weak but he is strong. Yes, Jesus loves me. Those words remind us that in the midst of death, Jesus brings life, and in the midst of evil, Jesus brings good. And he is with us through it all, even when we don’t realize it.
God does not live up to our expectations…our expectations that everything will be fine, that we will not suffer, that we will not experience pain…but God does fulfill His promise…that He loves us, that we are his children, that he will be with us, holding us, and loving us through every moment of our lives, giving us strength, giving us wisdom, giving us peace. We can go through life being frustrated that God does not live up to our expectations…or we can go through life being thankful that God always lives up to his promises to redeem us, to be present with us in our struggles, and to bring hope out of even the darkest times.
